Paying a collection does not remove it. The entry is updated to "paid" with a zero balance and can stay until about seven years after the date you first fell behind. A paid collection can still come off three ways: a dispute if something on it is wrong, a goodwill deletion from the collector, or age.
What paying does change
- Newer scoring models, FICO 9, FICO 10 and VantageScore 3.0 and 4.0, ignore paid collections.
- FICO 8, still widely used, counts a paid collection, but ignores any collection with an original balance under $100.
- Many mortgage lenders will not close a loan with an open collection, so "paid" matters to them even when the score does not move.
- A paid debt cannot be sold to another collector or lead to a lawsuit.
Medical collections are different
The three bureaus removed paid medical collections from credit reports in 2022 and stopped showing medical collections under $500 in 2023. If a paid medical collection is still on your report, dispute it. See medical collections.
Three ways a paid collection can come off
- Dispute what is wrong. Check the balance, the dates, the original creditor and whether it is listed twice. An entry that still shows a balance after you paid is an error. See duplicates and re-aged debt.
- Ask for a goodwill deletion. Write to the collector, say the account is paid, and ask it to delete the entry. It does not have to agree, and some do. See goodwill letter.
- Wait. It comes off about seven years after the date of first delinquency, and its effect on a score fades well before that.
If you have not paid yet
Your strongest moment is before you pay. Ask the collector to delete the entry in exchange for payment, and get the agreement in writing first. See pay for delete letter. For an old debt, check the statute of limitations before you pay or promise anything.
You can do this yourself for free