One debt may appear under the original creditor and under a collector, but only one entry should show a balance owed. If two entries both show the balance, if two collectors report the same debt at once, or if one collector lists it twice, that is a duplicate you can dispute.
Allowed, and not a duplicate
- The original creditor shows the account as charged off, sold or transferred, with a $0 balance.
- A collector shows the same debt with the balance.
Both entries are negative, but together they describe one debt once. See charge-off vs collection.
Errors you can dispute
- The original creditor and the collector both show a balance owed.
- Two collection agencies both report the debt as open. When a debt is sold again, the earlier collector no longer owns it.
- The same collector appears twice with different account numbers.
- The same account appears twice at one bureau with slightly different names.
How to check
- Get all three reports. A duplicate may be on one bureau only.
- For each collection, find the original creditor name and the original amount. Entries that match on both are probably the same debt.
- Compare the date of first delinquency. One debt has one date, no matter how many times it is sold.
How to dispute it
Write to each bureau showing the duplicate. Name both entries with their account numbers, say they are the same debt, and say which one should be removed or updated to a zero balance. If you know the debt was sold, say so. You can also send a debt validation letter to each collector to find out which one owns the debt now.
A different date on the newer entry is a separate problem: see re-aged debt.
You can do this yourself for free